Refusing the state's apartment zoning law has put up to $2.5 million in grants out of Winthrop's reach, its town manager says
Winthrop still refuses the state's MBTA Communities law. Its town manager puts the state grants lost or out of reach at up to $2.5 million. The plan its own Planning Board drew up would allow fewer homes than already stand in the two places it covers.
Would the state's apartment zoning law change your street in Winthrop? Under the plan the town's own Planning Board drew up in 2024, hardly at all.
That plan would apply the new zoning to two places that already hold about 790 homes, and allow fewer homes there than stand now. The Town Council has not adopted it. By Town Manager Tony Marino's count, saying no has put up to $2.5 million in state grants out of reach, counting grants Winthrop lost and ones it couldn't apply for. Winthrop is paying to avoid a rule that, under its own plan, would change little on its streets.
What does the law ask?
The MBTA Communities law, passed in 2021 and known as Section 3A, covers 177 cities and towns in and around the T's service area. Each must have at least one district, near a transit station if it has one, where apartment buildings are allowed as of right. That means no special permit, and no hearing on whether they can be built at all. The district must allow at least 15 homes an acre.
It does not make anyone build anything. It changes what an owner is allowed to build.
How big the district must be depends on the town. Winthrop has 8,821 homes, so the state says its zoning has to allow at least 882 homes, about one in ten, on at least 12 acres.
The plan on the shelf
In November 2024, after a year of work with consultants, the Planning Board voted unanimously for two districts. One runs along Seal Harbor Road and takes in Fort Heath. The other is Governors Park. Both already hold large apartment and condo complexes.
Those two areas hold about 790 homes today. The new zoning would allow about 670 there, roughly 60 fewer at each. No home would come down, and owners would have little reason to add any.
Counting what the town center's zoning already allows, the plan reached 890 homes, eight over the state's minimum. The state's housing office reviewed an early draft in October 2024 and sent back technical fixes. The council has twice voted, narrowly, against complying.
What has saying no cost?
The law spells out four state grant programs a holdout can't tap, including MassWorks, which pays for roads and water lines. State agencies have turned Winthrop down for other grants too. In August 2025, the state's environment office told Winthrop it would not get two flood-protection grants, for Morton Street and Fishermen's Bend, worth about $1.2 million together. It named the zoning law as the reason.
That October, the state passed Winthrop over for a $100,000 tree-planting grant; the program's manager said the town most likely would have won it had it complied.
Then the state cut off the Winthrop Parents Network, an early-learning program for families, which had received $45,700 a year. The network said in May 2026 that it would shut down. By early July 2026, the state had given the same amount to a Chelsea-based aid group to serve Winthrop children.
Counting grants the town can no longer apply for, Marino puts the total at up to $2.5 million. Council President Jim Letterie has said at least $300,000 of it is tied to schools. Marino has cautioned that complying would not guarantee all of it. Winthrop's whole yearly budget is about $68 million.
Where does the court case stand?
Attorney General Andrea Campbell sued Winthrop and eight other towns on Jan. 29, asking a judge to order each one to adopt a compliant district. Winthrop answered in March with claims of its own and asked for a jury. The attorney general moved to throw those claims out in April.
Rulings since then have gone against the law's opponents. Residents had brought a separate lawsuit against the law. A council vote to join it failed 4-4 in February; in April, the council voted 5-3 to back it. In July, a judge dismissed the suit. In September, the Supreme Judicial Court unanimously rejected Marshfield's challenge. That included the claim that the law is an unfunded mandate, which Winthrop also makes. It was the second time in two years the state's top court had upheld the law.
Repeal never reached voters. In January, Secretary of State William Galvin's office said all four ballot measures to repeal or weaken the law fell short of the signatures they needed. The Republican candidate for governor, Mike Minogue, had said he would end state enforcement of the law. He lost to Gov. Maura Healey on Nov. 3.
In October, the attorney general's office met Winthrop's lawyer to confirm the town's position. Town attorney James Cipoletta called it the last step before the state asks a judge to act.
The other road: Marblehead
Marblehead was sued the same day. It adopted a district at Town Meeting in May, and on Oct. 26 the state found its district compliant.
Its plan barely clears the bar, at about 900 homes against a required 897. The town's own model puts 780 of those homes on Tedesco Country Club, a private golf course. The law doesn't require the club to build any of them. Marblehead said it missed $3.77 million in grants while it held out. Those can't be recovered, but now that it complies, it can apply for future rounds.
Letterie and state Rep. Jeffrey Turco have raised the idea of putting Winthrop's district on its golf course. But Winthrop's course is owned by the town. Under the state's rules, town-owned land counts only in narrow cases. The town must have set it aside for housing or redevelopment, or the state must agree it suits apartment buildings that can go up there within a reasonable time. Letterie said in October that state officials gave no early sign they would accept it. Cipoletta said in October that state housing officials expect to answer within about two months if the town formally submits a golf course district.
What it means if you live in Winthrop
Three options are now on the table. The Planning Board's plan leaves the town much as it is. Putting the whole district at Governors Park could allow taller buildings there; Councilor Max Tassinari warned of 10 stories. A golf course district would open land that has no homes on it now.
If you own a condo at Seal Harbor, Fort Heath or Governors Park, it is your complex the Planning Board's zoning would cover. It would allow fewer homes than stand there now, so it gives little reason to build beside yours. Putting the whole district at Governors Park would open room for new buildings there, and only there. A district only on the golf course would leave all three complexes as they are zoned today.
About half the homes that sell in Winthrop are condos. None of the three options has changed what can be built yet. For now, Winthrop has more condos for sale than in summer. Since August, owners have listed about three for every one that found a buyer.
Since August, about three Winthrop condos have come up for sale for every one that found a buyer
Running totals for Winthrop condos, week by week. Each week starts on the Monday shown; the last runs Nov. 2 to Nov. 8, 2026.
- Condos newly listed, running total 58 (Nov. 2)
- Condos that found a buyer, running total 20 (Nov. 2)
Show the numbers
| Week | Condos newly listed, running total | Condos that found a buyer, running total |
|---|---|---|
| Aug. 10 | 7 | 3 |
| Aug. 17 | 10 | 4 |
| Aug. 24 | 15 | 6 |
| Aug. 31 | 18 | 8 |
| Sept. 7 | 28 | 10 |
| Sept. 14 | 36 | 12 |
| Sept. 21 | 39 | 12 |
| Sept. 28 | 43 | 14 |
| Oct. 5 | 48 | 15 |
| Oct. 12 | 52 | 15 |
| Oct. 19 | 54 | 18 |
| Oct. 26 | 58 | 20 |
| Nov. 2 | 58 | 20 |
The number for sale has grown, though by less than that suggests. Winthrop had 37 condos for sale in the week of Aug. 10. The count peaked at 54 in the week of Oct. 12 and has eased each week since, to 49 in the week of Nov. 2. Next door in Revere and Chelsea, fewer condos were for sale in November than in August.
In early November, Winthrop had a third more condos for sale than in August. Revere and Chelsea had fewer.
Condos for sale in each town, in the week of Aug. 10 and the week of Nov. 2, 2026.
Show the numbers
| Week of Aug. 10 | Week of Nov. 2 | Change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Winthrop | 37 | 49 | 32.4% |
| Revere | 36 | 33 | -8.3% |
| Chelsea | 51 | 41 | -19.6% |
If you are shopping for a condo, that means more to choose from right now. A typical Winthrop condo sold for $505,000 in the past 12 months, about $475 a square foot.
If you rent, a typical Winthrop two-bedroom lease signed in the past 12 months cost $2,600 a month. Only a golf course district or putting the whole district at Governors Park would let new apartment buildings go up, and that is how more apartments to choose from could come.
What comes next
Votes on the council are shifting. Letterie said in June he would vote to comply, and by October, the Winthrop Pilot reported, four of nine councilors backed it. On Nov. 10, Councilor Patrick Costigan said, "We will have to accept 3A, there's no question about that."
Two other towns sued in January are moving toward compliance: Tewksbury's Town Meeting approved a district in October, and Wilmington votes again on Nov. 21.
The next date to watch is in December. The council and the Planning Board plan to meet together then on Councilor Joseph Romano's proposals to limit building in the town center. One would lower the height limit there. Lower limits in the town center could leave the shelved plan short of the state's minimum, because it counted on homes the town center's zoning already allows.
Winthrop posts council and Planning Board agendas at winthropma.gov/AgendaCenter, and the December meeting will be listed there. Council meetings set aside time for public comment, where residents can speak for or against an option. If Winthrop holds out, the next date may be set by a judge, not the council.
How we measured
Sales are homes that closed in Winthrop in the 12 months to Nov. 14, 2026; leases are rentals that settled from Nov. 22, 2025 to Nov. 14, 2026. Price per square foot is for condos that listed a size. Weekly condo figures run from the week of Aug. 10 to the week of Nov. 2, 2026; a condo found a buyer when it went under agreement. Market figures come from verified market data. District sizes come from the Planning Board's November 2024 plan, the state's letter to Winthrop and news reports of the state's Oct. 26 ruling on Marblehead. Grant totals are each town's own estimates, as reported by the Winthrop Transcript, the Winthrop Pilot and the Marblehead Independent; the named grants come from the town manager's reports and from Boston.com and the Pilot.
Reported, written, fact-checked and published by the Observer's agentic newsroom. Every figure is checked against verified market data before it runs.
Agents and brokers: know something this story should say? Become a source and get quoted next time.
Sources
- Section 3A requires each MBTA community to have at least one district of reasonable size where multifamily housing is allowed as of right, at a minimum gross density of 15 units per acre, within half a mile of a transit station where there is one; a community that fails to comply is not eligible for the Housing Choice Initiative, the Local Capital Projects Fund, MassWorks or HousingWorks Mass. General Laws c.40A, section 3A: https://malegislature.gov/Laws/GeneralLaws/PartI/TitleVII/Chapter40A/Section3A
- MassWorks is the state's grant program for public infrastructure, including roads, water and sewer work Mass. Executive Office of Economic Development, MassWorks Infrastructure Program: https://www.mass.gov/service-details/massworks-infrastructure-program
- Under the state's regulation, publicly owned land, including land owned by a town, is excluded from the land that counts toward a district unless it is used by a local housing authority, is identified as a housing site in a housing production plan approved by the state, has been designated by its owner for disposition and redevelopment, or the state housing office finds, at the town's request, that it is suitable for multifamily housing and will be made available for it within a reasonable period; the definitions do not mention a lease 760 CMR 72.00, Multi-family zoning requirement for MBTA communities, section 72.02 Definitions (Developable public land; Excluded land; Publicly-owned land): https://www.mass.gov/regulations/760-CMR-7200-multi-family-zoning-requirement-for-mbta-communities
- Winthrop is an adjacent community with 8,821 homes (2020 Census); it must zone for at least 882 homes on at least 12 acres at 15 or more per acre; the state's early review of the town's draft listed technical fixes Mass. Executive Office of Housing and Livable Communities, pre-adoption review letter to Winthrop Town Manager Anthony Marino, Oct. 23, 2024: https://winthropma.gov/DocumentCenter/View/1684/EOHLC-Winthrop-Pre-adoption-Review-Feedback-Letter
- The Planning Board worked with consultants RKG Associates and Innes Associates throughout 2024 and voted unanimously on Nov. 12, 2024 to recommend two overlay districts, Seal Harbor Road (with Fort Heath) and Governors Park, which hold 394 and 393 homes today; the zoning would allow 333 and 336 homes there; with the town center counted, the plan reached 890 against 882 required Town of Winthrop Planning Board, compliance plan presentation, Nov. 12, 2024: https://winthropma.gov/DocumentCenter/View/1740/MBTA3AWPBCOMPLIANCE-PLAN11-12-24; Planning Board letter to the Town Council, Nov. 14, 2024: https://winthropma.gov/DocumentCenter/View/1741/MBTAWPBWRITTEN-RECOMMENDATIONTC11-12-24
- Town Manager Tony Marino tracks state grants Winthrop has been told it won't get and grants it could not apply for because it is not in compliance, with maximum totals of up to about $2.5 million, and cautions that compliance would not guarantee the full amount Winthrop Transcript, Town Manager tracks grant losses, April 16, 2026: http://winthroptranscript.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/WST-0415.pdf
- On Aug. 18, 2025 the state Executive Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs told Winthrop it would not receive two flood-protection grants, $819,829 for Morton Street and $405,020 for Fishermen's Bend, about $1.2 million in all, citing its noncompliance with the MBTA Communities law Boston.com, Winthrop loses $1.2M in climate grants over MBTA Communities Act noncompliance, Sept. 12, 2025: https://www.boston.com/news/local-news/2025/09/12/winthrop-loses-million-climate-grants/
- Winthrop, with a $68 million yearly budget, lost or became ineligible for about $2.5 million in state funding, at least $300,000 of it school-related, Letterie said; the council has twice voted narrowly against compliance; Council President Jim Letterie said he is ready to vote for compliance; the Winthrop Parents Network announced May 30 that its state funding was terminated and it would shut down Winthrop Pilot, Letterie willing to vote for 3A compliance, June 9, 2026: https://winthroppilot.com/2026/06/09/letterie-willing-to-vote-for-3a-compliance/
- The Winthrop Parents Network was denied state early education grant funding for fiscal 2027 because of Winthrop's non-compliance; its yearly grant since fiscal 2023 was $45,700 Town of Winthrop, Town Manager's report, June 2, 2026: https://winthropma.gov/DocumentCenter/View/3025/TM-REPORT-6-2-26
- By early July 2026 (reported July 3) the state Department of Early Education and Care awarded a $45,700 Coordinated Family and Community Engagement grant, the amount the Winthrop Parents Network had lost, to Community Action Programs Inter-City, a Chelsea-based aid group, to provide transition-to-kindergarten services for children in Winthrop Winthrop Pilot, State finds new route for child services funds, July 3, 2026: https://winthroppilot.com/2026/07/03/state-finds-new-route-for-child-services-funds/
- Winthrop lost a $100,000 state tree-planting grant (Cooling Corridors program, announced late October 2025, reported Nov. 21, 2025) over its non-compliance; the state's tree planting program manager said its application most likely would have been funded if the town was compliant; the state is still withholding money; AG representatives met town counsel to formally confirm the town's position, which town attorney James Cipoletta called the last step before the AG asks a judge to act; a private suit against the law was dismissed in July, and a majority of the Town Council had agreed to join that suit before it was thrown out; the golf course is town-owned; Council President Letterie and state Rep. Jeffrey Turco raised the idea of a golf course district; state housing officials declined to quickly endorse a golf course district, Council President Letterie said there were no early signals they would accept it, and town attorney James Cipoletta said the officials estimated an answer within about two months if Winthrop submitted it through the regular process; Letterie's switch left four of nine councilors backing compliance Winthrop Pilot, Winthrop tussles with state on 3A compliance plans, Oct. 22, 2026: https://winthroppilot.com/2026/10/22/winthrop-tussles-with-state-on-3a-compliance-plans/; Winthrop Pilot, Winthrop loses state trees grant, Nov. 21, 2025: https://winthroppilot.com/2025/11/21/winthrop-loses-state-trees-grant/
- The town posts Town Council and Planning Board agendas on its Agenda Center; council meeting agendas include public comment, which the council's rules place in its order of business Town of Winthrop, Agenda Center: https://www.winthropma.gov/AgendaCenter; Town Council agenda, Nov. 10, 2026: https://www.winthropma.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Agenda/_11102026-2186; Winthrop Town Council Rules and Procedures, Rule 4: https://www.winthropma.gov/DocumentCenter/View/1383/TC-RULES-PROCEDURESJUNE24UPDATE
- Nov. 10, 2026 council meeting: Councilor Patrick Costigan: 'We will have to accept 3A, there's no question about that.'; Letterie open to the Planning Board's plan; a proposal to put the whole district at Governors Park; Councilor Max Tassinari warned it could mean 10-story buildings; the council and the Planning Board will discuss together, at a meeting in December, Councilor Joseph Romano's proposals to limit construction in the town center, including new parking rules and lower building height limits Winthrop Pilot, Town Council retreats from housing battle, Nov. 11, 2026: https://winthroppilot.com/2026/11/11/town-council-retreats-from-housing-battle/
- A council motion to authorize the town to join the residents' 2024 lawsuit (Winthrop Says No to 3A Committee and Diana Viens) failed 4-4 on Feb. 3, 2026 Winthrop Transcript, Council motion to join 3A exemption fails, Feb. 5, 2026: https://winthroptranscript.com/2026/02/05/council-motion-to-join-3a-exemption-fails/
- On April 14, 2026 the council voted 5-3 for a resolution asking town officials to intervene in and support the plaintiffs in the private lawsuit; Judge Mark Gildea denied a town-backed request to halt enforcement of the law in Winthrop, saying the plaintiffs would appear not to have standing Winthrop Pilot, State court counters Winthrop suit against 3A, May 6, 2026: https://winthroppilot.com/2026/05/06/state-court-counters-winthrop-suit-against-3a/
- On Jan. 29, 2026 the Attorney General sued Dracut, East Bridgewater, Halifax, Holden, Marblehead, Middleton, Tewksbury, Wilmington and Winthrop, seeking court orders to create compliant districts; 165 of 177 communities had complied; the MBTA Communities law was signed in January 2021 Mass. Attorney General, AG Campbell sues nine communities for noncompliance with MBTA Communities law, Jan. 29, 2026: https://www.mass.gov/news/ag-campbell-sues-nine-communities-for-noncompliance-with-mbta-communities-law; GBH News, Jan. 29, 2026: https://www.wgbh.org/news/housing/2026-01-29/ag-campbell-sues-9-towns-for-noncompliance-with-mbta-act
- Winthrop filed an answer, defenses and counterclaims on March 19, 2026, and asked for a jury; the AG moved to dismiss or strike them on April 16, 2026; Winthrop argues the law is an unfunded mandate A Better City, Policy update: MBTA Communities law status and housing outlook, May 2026: https://www.abettercity.org/news-and-events/blog/policy-update-mbta-communities-law-status-and-housing-outlook
- The Supreme Judicial Court upheld the law in Attorney General v. Town of Milton (Jan. 8, 2025) and unanimously rejected Marshfield's challenge, including its unfunded-mandate claim, on Sept. 18, 2026 (Marshfield v. Commonwealth, SJC-13840) Justia, Attorney General v. Town of Milton, SJC-13580: https://law.justia.com/cases/massachusetts/supreme-court/2025/sjc-13580.html; Winthrop Pilot, SJC again upholds MBTA Communities housing law, Sept. 18, 2026: https://winthroppilot.com/2026/09/18/sjc-again-upholds-mbta-communities-housing-law/
- Republican nominee Mike Minogue said he would end state enforcement of the law; Gov. Maura Healey won re-election on Nov. 3, 2026 GBH News, GOP's Minogue rolls out his pitch for governor ahead of the general, Sept. 10, 2026: https://www.wgbh.org/news/politics/2026-09-10/gops-minogue-rolls-out-his-pitch-for-governor-ahead-of-the-general; GBH News, Nov. 3, 2026: https://www.wgbh.org/news/politics/2026-11-03/im-going-to-work-my-hardest-healey-wins-second-term-as-mass-governor
- Secretary of State William Galvin announced that all four proposed 2026 ballot measures seeking to repeal or weaken the MBTA Communities Act fell short of the signatures needed to advance Citizens' Housing and Planning Association (CHAPA), Key housing legislation, MBTA Communities Act, to persevere as ballot measures fail to reach signature threshold, Jan. 8, 2026: https://chapa.org/key-housing-legislation-mbta-communities-act-to-persevere-as-ballot-measures-fail-to-reach-signature-threshold/; Ballotpedia, Massachusetts Repeal Multi-Family Zoning Requirements in MBTA Communities Initiative (2026): https://ballotpedia.org/Massachusetts_Repeal_Multi-Family_Zoning_Requirements_in_MBTA_Communities_Initiative_(2026)
- Marblehead adopted its district at its May 2026 Town Meeting; the state found it compliant on Oct. 26, 2026: 40.8 acres, about 900 homes against a minimum of 897; the town's model puts 780 of the 900 at the privately owned Tedesco Country Club; a town worksheet listed $3.77 million in grants lost while out of compliance; the law does not require housing to be built; grants from rounds already closed can't be recovered, but compliance makes the town eligible for future rounds Marblehead Independent, State rules Marblehead compliant with MBTA zoning law, accepting golf course plan, Oct. 26, 2026: https://www.marbleheadindependent.com/state-rules-marblehead-compliant-with-mbta-zoning-law-accepting-golf-course-plan/; Marblehead Current, Oct. 26, 2026: https://marbleheadcurrent.org/2026/10/26/breaking-news-state-awards-3a-compliance-to-marblehead/; Marblehead Weekly News: https://marbleheadweeklynews.com/marblehead-meets-mbta-communities-zoning-law-state-says/
- Tewksbury Town Meeting approved an MBTA Communities district in October 2026; Wilmington votes again at a special Town Meeting on Nov. 21 Mass Transit (from The Sun, Lowell), Oct. 21, 2026: https://www.masstransitmag.com/management/news/55413330/ma-wilmington-town-meeting-to-consider-mbta-communities-again
- Winthrop, past 12 months: 179 homes sold, 91 of them condos; typical condo $505,000, about $475 a square foot; typical two-bedroom rent $2,600 a month (61 leases) Verified market data: Winthrop closed sales in the 12 months to Nov. 14, 2026, and leases settled Nov. 22, 2025 to Nov. 14, 2026; re-run Nov. 15, 2026
- Winthrop condos, weeks of Aug. 10 to Nov. 2, 2026: 58 new listings, 20 went under agreement; condos for sale 37 in the week of Aug. 10, a peak of 54 in the week of Oct. 12, then 52, 51 and 49 in the week of Nov. 2 (Revere 36 and 33, Chelsea 51 and 41); 47 for sale on Nov. 14 Verified market data: weekly Winthrop, Revere and Chelsea condo figures, re-run Nov. 15, 2026